For middle-market CEOs and business leaders, the day-to-day focus is almost always on operational excellence, revenue growth and market share. However, the metrics that drive a company’s value — particularly from an investor or buyer perspective — often differ from those used to judge daily performance.
Understanding what truly drives value requires looking beyond internal performance and evaluating the business through the lens of future cash flow and risk. Companies that generate stable, predictable earnings and demonstrate lower risk profiles are typically rewarded with higher valuations.
Smart Business spoke with Brent Michalak, Business Valuation Supervisor at Corrigan Krause, about key value drivers, the diagnostic role of a formal business valuation and why these assessments are critical long before a sale is on the horizon.
What are the primary value drivers in a business?
One of the most critical value drivers is management depth — the distribution of responsibilities amongst leadership and organizational strength beyond the owner. A significant risk factor is key-person dependency, where a business relies too heavily on one or two individuals to maintain operations or customer relationships.
Customer diversification is another major factor. A company with revenue spread across multiple customers is generally more valuable than one dependent on a single client. While owners often emphasize strong relationships with key customers, outside investors may view that concentration as risk if those relationships are not easily transferable.
Sustainable earnings and cash flow are also primary value drivers, with an emphasis on consistency and predictability. Some businesses experienced temporary sales spikes during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, if those increases were not sustainable, valuations may be moderated because buyers focus on normalized, forward-looking performance.
Other under-recognized factors include financial reporting quality, operational efficiency and a formal succession plan. These may not impact daily operations but are often scrutinized early in the transaction process because they directly influence perceived risk.
How does a business valuation differ from a quality of earnings report?
A business valuation is a strategic tool that helps leadership identify where to focus to strengthen the business. This independent analysis estimates the fair market value of a company using established methodologies, including the income, market and asset approaches. It also serves as a diagnostic tool, evaluating normalized profitability, growth trends and company-specific risks to determine how those factors impact value.
A quality of earnings analysis does not assign a value. It is typically used during due diligence to assess the sustainability of earnings by identifying unusual or non-recurring items.
While both analyses are important, a valuation provides a broader strategic perspective, including market-based insight into how risk and performance influence value. Further, because a business is often an owner’s largest personal asset, understanding how that value is created helps inform long-term decisions related to growth, capital investment, financing and future liquidity events. It also ensures that leadership is prepared for unexpected opportunities.
Who should perform this work and what is the recommended frequency?
Leaders should work with professionals holding recognized credentials, such as Certified Valuation Analyst (CVA), Accredited in Business Valuation (ABV), or Accredited Senior Appraiser (ASA).
An annual valuation is ideal. The initial engagement is more comprehensive, requiring several years of historical financial analysis and management interviews, but subsequent updates can be more streamlined and cost-effective. Regular valuations allow leadership to track progress, measure improvements in key value drivers and stay aligned with long-term goals. They also help ensure the business remains positioned to maximize value.
Ultimately, the valuation process provides insight into how the market may view a company and where opportunities exist to enhance value. ●
INSIGHTS Accounting is brought to you by Corrigan Krause.
